pictureFrame-webApp/_bmad-output/planning-artifacts/test-plan.md

status, createdAt, reviewedBy

status	createdAt	reviewedBy
reviewed	2026-05-06	ProductOwner Architect DevLead

pictureFrame — Comprehensive Test Plan

0. Scope and Goals

This plan covers unit, integration, and functional tests for all three layers of the pictureFrame system:

1. Server — Symfony 8 / PHP 8.4 backend (controllers, services, message handlers, repositories)
2. Frontend — Vue 3 SPA (stores, components, views)
3. Firmware — ESP32 Arduino C++ (control flow, protocol correctness)

Primary goals:

• Prevent regressions in the firmware ↔ server API contract (any break requires physical reflash of every deployed device)
• Cover all branching logic in RotationService and DeviceImageController — the most complex, failure-prone code
• FW-02 is the explicit regression test for the NVS header-read-after-end bug (headers read after http.end() → NVS never updated → 304 never fires)
• Give CI a green/red signal before any server deploy

---

1. Tooling and Infrastructure

1.1 PHP / Server

Tool	Role	Already present?
PHPUnit 13.1	Unit + integration + functional test runner	Yes (phpunit.dist.xml, tests/bootstrap.php)
symfony/test-pack	WebTestCase, KernelTestCase, test client	Needs adding
dama/doctrine-test-bundle	Wraps each test in a rolled-back transaction (fast isolation)	Needs adding
doctrine/fixtures-bundle	Seed fixture objects without raw SQL	Needs adding
Separate test database	_test suffix already in doctrine.yaml	Configured, DB needs creating

Required setup steps (all inside ddev exec):

# Install test dependencies
ddev exec composer require --dev symfony/test-pack dama/doctrine-test-bundle doctrine/fixtures-bundle

# Create test DB and run migrations
ddev exec php bin/console doctrine:database:create --env=test
ddev exec php bin/console doctrine:migrations:migrate --no-interaction --env=test

phpunit.dist.xml — add dama extension:

<extensions>
    <bootstrap class="DAMA\DoctrineTestBundle\PHPUnit\PHPUnitExtension"/>
</extensions>

.env.test.local (not committed — each developer creates this):

DATABASE_URL="pgsql://db:db@db:5432/pictureframe_test"

.env.test — add Messenger transport override so dispatched messages are observable in integration tests:

MESSENGER_TRANSPORT_DSN=in-memory://

Without this, RenderImageMessage dispatch assertions (IMG-01, SH-03, IMG-06) will silently not fire.

Filesystem teardown for message handler tests: dama/doctrine-test-bundle rolls back DB writes but NOT filesystem writes. Tests in RenderImageMessageHandlerTest that write .bin files to storage/images/ must call a teardown that deletes the test image directory after each test. Use setUp()/tearDown() with a dedicated storage/test/ prefix, or run handler tests in a separate suite without dama.

1.2 Frontend

Tool	Role	Already present?
Vitest 2.x	Unit + component test runner (Vite-native)	Needs adding
@vue/test-utils	Mount Vue components in JSDOM	Needs adding
@vitest/coverage-v8	Coverage reporting	Needs adding
MSW 2.x	Intercept fetch() calls in tests	Needs adding

Add to frontend/package.json devDependencies, then add test block to vite.config.ts:

test: {
  environment: 'jsdom',
  globals: true,
  setupFiles: ['./src/test/setup.ts'],
}

Known gap: CropEditor.vue and StickerCanvas.vue depend on Konva.js canvas APIs unavailable in JSDOM. These two components are excluded from component tests and do NOT count toward the 60% component coverage target. They require Playwright E2E or manual testing.

1.3 Firmware

Tool	Role	Already present?
PlatformIO native env	Compiles C++ for host, runs Unity tests	Needs adding
Unity (bundled)	Assertions and test runner macros	Bundled
Hand-rolled Arduino mocks	Stubs for Arduino/ESP APIs	Needs writing

platformio.ini additions:

[env:native-test]
platform = native
lib_deps =
    throwtheswitch/Unity@^2.6
build_flags = -DUNIT_TEST -Itest/mocks
test_build_src = no

test_build_src = no is required — yes would compile setup() and loop() from main.cpp for the host, colliding with PlatformIO's native main() shim (ODR violation / duplicate symbol linker error).

HTTPClient injection — template, not polymorphism: Arduino's HTTPClient methods are not virtual, so normal_operation() cannot accept an HTTPClient& base reference. Use a compile-time template instead:

template<typename HTTP>
static void normal_operation_impl(const String& mac, HTTP& http) { ... }

// Production:
static void normal_operation(const String& mac) {
    WiFiClientSecure client;
    client.setInsecure();
    HTTPClient http;
    http.begin(client, url);
    normal_operation_impl(mac, http);
}

The mock HTTP type and the real HTTPClient share no base class — the template resolves at compile time. Production code is unchanged in behavior; tests instantiate with a mock type.

Mock surface — all files in firmware/test/mocks/ (included before system headers via -Itest/mocks build flag):

Mock file	Stubs	Notes
Arduino.h	millis(), delay(), pinMode(), digitalRead(), String, Serial
MockHTTPClient.h	begin(), GET(), header(), end(), writeToStream(), addHeader(), collectHeaders()	header() must return empty string after end() is called — this is the FW-02 behavior
WiFi.h	macAddress(), status(), begin(), mode(), softAP(), softAPIP(), localIP()
WiFiClientSecure.h	No-op constructor, setInsecure()
Preferences.h	In-memory std::map-backed getInt(), putInt(), getString(), putString(), clear(), begin(), end()
LittleFS.h / FS.h	In-memory file store; writeToStream() in MockHTTPClient pumps into this store	The wiring between HTTPClient mock and LittleFS mock must be explicit — mock HTTP holds a pointer to mock FS
epd.h	No-op stubs + call counters for each epd_* function	Shadows real header via -Itest/mocks — do NOT put mocks in firmware/src/
esp_sleep.h	Captures sleepUs in a global; separate g_deepSleepStarted boolean	Both esp_sleep_enable_timer_wakeup and esp_deep_sleep_start must be mocked

---

2. Server Tests

Test taxonomy

Label used in this plan	Symfony base class	Scope
Unit	PHPUnit\Framework\TestCase	Pure PHP logic, mock repositories — no DB, no container
Integration	KernelTestCase + dama	Real DB, real container, no HTTP routing
Functional	WebTestCase + dama	Full HTTP stack: routing, firewall, kernel

2.1 Unit Tests — RotationService

File: tests/Unit/Service/RotationServiceTest.php

Uses PHPUnit\Framework\TestCase with mock EntityManager and DeviceImageHistoryRepository. No DB, no container — pure selection algorithm logic.

#	Test	What it asserts
R-01	advance_returns_null_when_pool_empty	No ready RenderedAssets → advance() returns null
R-02	advance_picks_oldest_image_with_no_history	Pool of 3 images, no history → returns oldest by uploadedAt
R-03	advance_skips_recently_shown_image	Image A shown last → Image B returned next
R-04	advance_resets_when_all_candidates_in_window	All pool images in uniqueness window → picks from full pool (no infinite loop)
R-05	advance_respects_uniqueness_window_size	Window=2, pool=5 → only 2 IDs excluded
R-06	advance_writes_DeviceImageHistory_record	em->persist() called with a DeviceImageHistory for the returned image
R-07	advance_updates_device_current_image	$device->getCurrentImage() matches returned image
R-08	advance_only_considers_ready_assets	Image with pending RenderedAsset excluded from pool
R-09	advance_respects_device_approved_images_only	Image not approved for this device excluded from pool
R-10	advance_not_called_when_device_has_locked_image	Controller bypasses advance() entirely when lockedImage set — assert advance() is never reached (test via controller, see I-06)

2.2 Unit Tests — TokenService

File: tests/Unit/Service/TokenServiceTest.php

#	Test	What it asserts
T-01	issue_creates_token_with_correct_type	Returns Token with matching TokenType
T-02	issue_sets_expiry_in_future	expiresAt > now()
T-03	consume_marks_token_used	usedAt is set on the persisted entity
T-04	consume_returns_token_entity	Return value is the Token object
T-05	consume_throws_on_expired_token	Token past expiresAt → exception
T-06	consume_throws_on_already_used_token	usedAt already set → exception
T-07	consume_throws_on_type_mismatch	Requesting wrong TokenType → exception

2.3 Unit Tests — DeviceService

File: tests/Unit/Service/DeviceServiceTest.php

#	Test	What it asserts
D-01	link_associates_device_with_user	$device->getUser() matches after link
D-02	link_idempotent_for_same_user	Calling link twice does not throw or create duplicates
D-03	purgeHistory_removes_records_beyond_window	History older than uniqueness window count is deleted
D-04	re_provision_clears_history_and_transfers_ownership	Physical reset (clear credentials) wipes DeviceImageHistory and sets user = null on device — FR9 security invariant

2.4 Functional Tests — DeviceImageController

File: tests/Functional/Controller/DeviceImageControllerTest.php

Uses WebTestCase. This is the highest-value test class — it covers the entire firmware-facing API contract.

#	Route	Setup	Expected response
I-01	GET /api/device/{unknownMac}/image	MAC not in DB	404
I-02	GET /api/device/{mac}/image	Device exists, no approved images	204
I-03	GET /api/device/{mac}/image	One ready image, no X-Current-Image-Id	200, body is binary, X-Image-Id set, X-Interval-Ms set
I-04	GET /api/device/{mac}/image + X-Current-Image-Id: {id}	ID matches current image	304, no body, headers still set
I-05	GET /api/device/{mac}/image + X-Current-Image-Id: {staleId}	ID does NOT match current image	200, new image served
I-06	GET /api/device/{mac}/image	Locked image set, no X-Current-Image-Id	200, locked image served; RotationService::advance() NOT called (spy/mock)
I-07	GET /api/device/{mac}/image + X-Current-Image-Id: {lockedId}	Locked image = current image	304
I-08	GET /api/device/{mac}/image twice, second call changes image	Rotation advances: first call returns Image A, second call (different X-Current-Image-Id) returns Image B	Use a single-request test asserting currentImage changed in DB, not two HTTP calls through dama rollback
I-09	GET /api/device/{mac}/image	X-Interval-Ms value	rotationIntervalMinutes * 60 * 1000, bounded by server ceiling
I-10	GET /api/device/{mac}/image 200 response	lastSeenAt side effect	device.lastSeenAt updated after 200 poll
I-11	GET /api/device/{mac}/image 304 response	lastSeenAt side effect	device.lastSeenAt also updated after 304 — a 304 is a successful poll

2.5 Functional Tests — DeviceApiController

File: tests/Functional/Controller/DeviceApiControllerTest.php

#	Route	Notes
A-01	GET /api/devices (authenticated)	Returns only requesting user's devices
A-02	GET /api/devices (unauthenticated)	401
A-03	PATCH /api/devices/{id}	Updates name, orientation, rotationIntervalMinutes
A-04	PATCH /api/devices/{id} — wrong user	403 / 404
A-05	PUT /api/devices/{id}/lock	Sets lockedImage, response includes lockedImageId
A-06	PUT /api/devices/{id}/lock — image not approved for device	422
A-07	DELETE /api/devices/{id}/lock	Clears lockedImage, response has lockedImageId: null
A-08	PUT /api/devices/{id}/lock — wrong user's device	403

2.6 Functional Tests — ImageApiController

File: tests/Functional/Controller/ImageApiControllerTest.php

#	Route	Notes
IMG-01	POST /api/images	Valid upload → 201, Image in DB, RenderImageMessage in in-memory transport
IMG-02	POST /api/images	No file → 422
IMG-03	GET /api/images	Returns authenticated user's images with thumbnail/original URLs
IMG-04	DELETE /api/images/{id}	Soft-deletes image (deletedAt set, row still exists)
IMG-05	DELETE /api/images/{id} — wrong user	403
IMG-06	POST /api/images/{id}/reprocess	New RenderImageMessage in in-memory transport

2.7 Functional Tests — SharedImageApiController

File: tests/Functional/Controller/SharedImageApiControllerTest.php

#	Route	Notes
SH-01	GET /api/shared	Paginated result, totalPages/total/page fields correct
SH-02	GET /api/shared?status=pending	Filters by status
SH-03	PUT /api/shared/{id}/approve	Status → approved, RenderImageMessage in in-memory transport
SH-04	PUT /api/shared/{id}/decline	Status → declined
SH-05	PUT /api/shared/{id}/approve — wrong user	403
SH-06	Approve → image enters rotation pool	After approval + render, image appears in RotationService::readyPool() for the recipient's device

2.8 Functional Tests — TokenActionController

File: tests/Functional/Controller/TokenActionControllerTest.php

#	Test	Notes
TK-01	Valid share_approve token	Approval performed, token marked used, redirected
TK-02	Expired token	404 or 410
TK-03	Already-used token	404 or 410
TK-04	Wrong token type	404
TK-05	hard_delete_confirm token	Image hard-deleted from DB and storage

2.9 Functional Tests — SetupController

File: tests/Functional/Controller/SetupControllerTest.php

#	Route	Notes
S-01	GET /setup/{mac} — new device	Shows registration/login form
S-02	GET /setup/{mac} — already-linked device	Redirects to configure step
S-03	POST /setup/{mac}/register	Creates User, links Device to User
S-04	POST /setup/{mac}/register — duplicate email	Validation error
S-05	POST /setup/{mac}/configure	Saves name, orientation, rotationIntervalMinutes

2.10 Functional Tests — SecurityController

File: tests/Functional/Controller/SecurityControllerTest.php

#	Route	Notes
SEC-01	POST /login valid credentials	Session cookie set, redirected
SEC-02	POST /login wrong password	Error message, no session
SEC-03	POST /register	Creates user with hashed password
SEC-04	POST /register duplicate email	Form error

2.11 Integration Tests — Message Handlers

Note: These tests run without dama/doctrine-test-bundle transaction wrapping because they write to the filesystem. Run in a separate PHPUnit suite (tests/Integration/) with their own teardown strategy: each test uses a unique storage/test/{uuid}/ path, cleaned up in tearDown().

File: tests/Integration/MessageHandler/RenderImageMessageHandlerTest.php

Requires Imagick installed (present in DDEV via php8.4-imagick). Run ddev exec — not on host.

#	Test	Notes
MH-01	Valid image + device model	RenderedAsset.status = ready, .bin file written to storage path
MH-01b	4bpp palette contract	Reads first bytes of written .bin; asserts palette indices match Spectra 6 map (BLACK=0x0, WHITE=0x1, YELLOW=0x2, RED=0x3, BLUE=0x5, GREEN=0x6) — prevents a server-side Imagick palette bug from silently producing a garbled display
MH-02	Missing source image file	RenderedAsset.status = failed, no uncaught exception
MH-03	Both orientations	Two RenderedAsset rows for same image (landscape + portrait)

File: tests/Integration/MessageHandler/RunImageCleanupMessageHandlerTest.php

#	Test	Notes
CL-01	Image past retention with approvals	Soft-delete flag set
CL-02	Image past retention with no approvals	Hard-deleted from DB and storage
CL-03	Recent image	Untouched

---

3. Frontend Tests

3.1 Store Tests

tests/frontend/stores/devices.test.ts

#	Test	Notes
DS-01	fetchDevices success	devices populated, loading false
DS-02	fetchDevices network error	error set, devices empty
DS-03	updateDevice patches local array	devices[idx] updated after PATCH
DS-04	lockImage sets lockedImageId on local device	Updated from server response
DS-05	unlockImage clears lockedImageId	null in local state

tests/frontend/stores/images.test.ts

#	Test	Notes
IM-01	fetchImages success	images populated
IM-02	Upload workflow state transitions	setFile → setCrop → setStickers → setDevices in correct order
IM-03	pendingCount computed	Reflects status === 'pending' images

tests/frontend/stores/auth.test.ts

#	Test	Notes
AU-01	Bootstraps from window.__BOOTSTRAP_USER__	user set, isAuthenticated true
AU-02	No bootstrap data	isAuthenticated false

tests/frontend/stores/toast.test.ts

#	Test	Notes
TO-01	push adds message	Queue length +1
TO-02	Auto-dismiss after 2.5s	Queue empty after timeout (Vitest fake timers)

3.2 Component Tests

tests/frontend/components/FrameCard.test.ts

#	Test	Notes
FC-01	Status "ok" renders green badge	lastSeenAt recent
FC-02	Status "sync-fail" renders yellow badge	lastSeenAt >2× interval ago
FC-03	Status "no-wifi" badge	lastSeenAt null

tests/frontend/components/BaseButton.test.ts

#	Test	Notes
BB-01	Loading spinner when loading=true	Label hidden
BB-02	Disabled when disabled=true	disabled attribute present
BB-03	Emits click when not disabled

tests/frontend/components/DevicePicker.test.ts

#	Test	Notes
DP-01	Selecting device emits update:modelValue
DP-02	Deselecting removes from list
DP-03	Pre-selected devices shown as checked

tests/frontend/components/ShareSheet.test.ts

#	Test	Notes
SS-01	Valid email submits share API call	POST /api/share intercepted by MSW
SS-02	Empty email shows validation error, no API call
SS-03	Success closes sheet

3.3 View Integration Tests

tests/frontend/views/LibraryView.test.ts

#	Test	Notes
LV-01	Mounted in "uploaded" tab	Image grid renders
LV-02	Switch to "shared" tab	fetchShared called, ApproveCards render
LV-03	Lock chip shown for approved devices	Chip present below image
LV-04	Unlocked chip click calls lockImage	Store action called
LV-05	Locked chip (solid) click calls unlockImage	Store action called
LV-06	Share button opens ShareSheet	shareSheetOpen true
LV-07	Empty library state	Empty-state prompt visible when images.length === 0

tests/frontend/views/HomeView.test.ts

#	Test	Notes
HV-01	Renders FrameCard for each device	N cards for N devices
HV-02	Empty state shown when no devices	Prompt/empty message visible

---

4. Firmware Tests

4.1 Architecture

PlatformIO native env (test_build_src = no) compiles only firmware/test/ test files and the specific source files they include explicitly. setup() and loop() from main.cpp are excluded — they would collide with PlatformIO's native main() shim.

The testable logic in main.cpp is extracted into:

• operation.cpp / operation.h — normal_operation_impl<HTTP>(mac, http) template function
• provisioning.cpp / provisioning.h — ap_ssid_from_mac(), attempt_wifi()

epd.h is shadowed by firmware/test/mocks/epd.h via the -Itest/mocks build flag in [env:native-test].

4.2 Unit Tests — normal_operation_impl() control flow

File: firmware/test/test_normal_operation.cpp

#	Setup	Expected
FW-01	HTTP 200, X-Image-Id: 42, X-Interval-Ms: 60000	File written to mock FS, epd_draw_image_from_file call count = 1, NVS img_id = 42, sleep = 60000ms, g_deepSleepStarted = true
FW-02	HTTP 200, assert header read order	newId is "42" (non-empty) — verifies headers read BEFORE http.end(). Regression test for NVS bug.
FW-03	HTTP 304	epd_init call count = 0, epd_draw_image_from_file call count = 0, sleep set from X-Interval-Ms, g_deepSleepStarted = true
FW-04	HTTP 204	show_setup_qr (or epd_draw_setup_screen) call count = 1, epd_draw_image_from_file call count = 0
FW-05	HTTP 404	show_setup_qr call count = 1
FW-06	HTTP 500	epd_fill(COLOR_YELLOW) called
FW-07	NVS has saved img_id = 99	X-Current-Image-Id: 99 present in request headers sent by mock HTTP
FW-08	NVS img_id at default (-1)	X-Current-Image-Id header NOT added to request
FW-09	X-Interval-Ms: 120000, FETCH_INTERVAL_MS = 300000	sleepMs = 120000 (server value honored, within ceiling)
FW-10	X-Interval-Ms: 600000, FETCH_INTERVAL_MS = 300000	sleepMs = 300000 (capped at firmware ceiling)
FW-11	X-Interval-Ms absent	sleepMs = FETCH_INTERVAL_MS (default)

4.3 Unit Tests — Provisioning

File: firmware/test/test_provisioning.cpp

#	Test	Expected
FW-12	MAC AA:BB:CC:DD:EE:FF	SSID = PictureFrame-EEFF
FW-13	MAC 1C:C3:AB:D1:91:F8	SSID = PictureFrame-91F8
FW-14	WiFi connects within timeout	attempt_wifi() returns true
FW-15	WiFi never connects	attempt_wifi() returns false after WIFI_TIMEOUT_MS
FW-16	WiFi connect fails → re-provisioning	loop() on attempt_wifi() failure: epd_fill(COLOR_RED) called, then enter_provisioning() called — confirms provisioning state machine re-enters correctly

4.4 Unit Tests — Button-hold re-provisioning

File: firmware/test/test_reset_button.cpp

#	Test	Expected
FW-17	digitalRead(PIN_BTN_RESET) returns LOW for ≥ RESET_HOLD_MS	clear_creds = true, prefs.clear() called, provisioning mode entered
FW-18	Button released before RESET_HOLD_MS	clear_creds = false, normal boot continues

---

5. Coverage Targets

Layer	Target	Priority
RotationService	100% line	Critical
DeviceImageController	100% line	Critical
TokenService	95%+	High
All other src/Service/	80%+	High
All src/Controller/	80%+	High
src/MessageHandler/	85%+	High (rendering pipeline is high-risk)
Frontend stores	80%+	High
Frontend components	60%+ (excluding CropEditor, StickerCanvas)	Medium
Firmware control flow (operation.cpp)	90%+ branches	High

---

6. CI Integration

All three suites must pass before merge to master.

# Server
ddev exec php bin/phpunit --coverage-text

# Firmware
cd firmware && pio test -e native-test

# Frontend
cd frontend && npx vitest run --coverage

---

7. Implementation Order

Phase 1 — Server functional + integration tests (highest ROI, minimal new tooling)

1. composer require --dev symfony/test-pack dama/doctrine-test-bundle doctrine/fixtures-bundle
2. Register dama extension in phpunit.dist.xml
3. Add MESSENGER_TRANSPORT_DSN=in-memory:// to .env.test
4. Create + migrate test DB
5. Write DeviceImageControllerTest (I-01 through I-11) — covers the firmware API contract
6. Write RotationServiceTest (R-01 through R-09) — pure unit, no DB
7. Write remaining controller + service tests

Phase 2 — Firmware native tests (second priority — protects the one thing that requires a physical reflash)

1. Extract normal_operation_impl<HTTP>() template into operation.cpp
2. Add [env:native-test] to platformio.ini (test_build_src = no)
3. Write mock headers in firmware/test/mocks/
4. Write test_normal_operation.cpp (FW-01 through FW-11, FW-02 is the regression test)
5. Write test_provisioning.cpp (FW-12 through FW-16)
6. Write test_reset_button.cpp (FW-17 through FW-18)

Phase 3 — Frontend unit tests

1. Add Vitest + @vue/test-utils + MSW to package.json
2. Add test block to vite.config.ts
3. Write store tests (no DOM needed — fastest to write)
4. Write component tests

Phase 4 — CI pipeline

1. Add Gitea Actions workflow
2. Wire all three test commands in sequence

---

8. Known Gaps (explicitly out of scope for V1 tests)

• CropEditor.vue and StickerCanvas.vue — Konva.js canvas not testable in JSDOM; require Playwright E2E
• Admin moderation panel (AdminModerationController) — not yet implemented
• Collections approval (FR21) — not yet implemented
• E-ink display pixel-level rendering correctness — no practical automated test; validated by eye on hardware
• Interval timing drift accuracy (±5 min PRD requirement) — requires a time-series integration test; deferred to post-V1